For the Love of Scottish Music: James Davie (ca.1783-1857)

Images of Aberdeen from Pixabay

The majority of the historical individuals I’ve encountered during my research have shared a common interest: the love of Scottish music. Aberdonian James Davie certainly falls into this category. His absolute obsession with old Scots tunes and music books does suggest he might nowadays have been diagnosed as somewhere ‘on the spectrum’, but if someone is going to have a special interest, then collecting Scottish music is really a perfectly acceptable one. Well, it seems reasonable to me!

David Baptie, in his Musical Scotland, described him as ‘a man possessed of taste and ability’, noting that he was born around 1783 and died on this day, 19 November, in 1857.

David Baptie, Musical Scotland: Past and Present (1894) p.41

From my point of view, Davie was a close friend of, and collaborator with Dundee collector Andrew Wighton (whose collection is now in the Wighton Centre, Dundee Central Library). I mentioned the other day, a letter written in old age when he despaired that he and Wighton would find anything else of interest in the antiquarian Scottish music field. There are letters to Wighton witnessing Davie’s absolute hatred of English antiquarian ballad collector William Chappell. And what had Chappell done? In his Popular Music of Olden Times, which came out in separate issues before becoming a book, Chappell had claimed that ….

Shock, horror ….!

… some tunes that were claimed to be Scottish, were actually English. (I’m whispering this.)

You can read about the whole argument in my monograph, Our Ancient National Airs, more affordable as paperback or on Kindle, or most affordable by borrowing it from a university or public library!

Remembered for Davie’s Caledonian Repository

I’m not sure, but I have a feeling Davie’s wife predeceased him – I recall him mentioning her not being in good health, in one of his letters to Wighton. So, he may well have been a sad and lonely old man. Certainly, in old age, James Davie became exceptionally grumpy. Perfectly lucid, but very, very bitter. So today, on the 169th anniversary of his death, perhaps I should end with some happier thoughts – he was a flautist, composer and teacher, and published several music collections. I’ve seen one or two of them, but haven’t studied them, as such. There are a number of copies of Davie’s Caledonian Repository extant, largely in a few legal deposit libraries, but also in the Dundonian Wighton Collection. Baptie spoke highly of him, and Wighton was a good friend. And he loved Scottish music!

Image of Aberdeen views by Artex Studio from Pixabay