Dr Karen McAulay explores the history of Scottish music collecting, publishing and national identity from the 18th to 20th centuries. Research Fellow at Royal Conservatoire of Scotland, author of two Routledge monographs.
Yesterday, I noted the death of one of Chappell’s critics, in 1857. As fate would have it, today (20 November) is William Chappell’s 217th birthday.
Whilst his comments in Popular Music of theOlden Time impinged on my own research into Scottish song collecting in the Victorian era, his interests were actually considerably wider, and he was involved in publishing as well as writing about music. Anyway, having noted the date, I’ll leave it at that. I may have blogged enough this week!
After doing my Leng Medal Memories interviews, I have twenty-seven transcriptions of half-hour interviews, not to mention other responses which I may wish to draw upon. The easiest way to write an article is just to sit and write about what I remember. This is a good start. But when my research is so rich in detail, I really do want to include plenty of quotes and examples in whatever I write. And I dread omitting something really important!
I have spreadsheets, oh yes indeed. Who I interviewed, when they entered the Leng Scots song competitions, what school(s) they attended, which songs they sang … and that’s just for starters.
But it’s not enough.
Choices, Choices!
I toyed with the idea of creating a table with tick-boxes, so I could search on individual terms, but that wouldn’t work. If all the terms were on the table, and the table went at the top of every transcription, then every keyword would be in every transcription. How about, I mused, using the table and simply deleting concepts that WEREN’T discussed. It felt a bit like rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic. It would take hours, and STILL I wouldn’t have arranged the data that I wanted to useinto anything like useable order.
I visualised myself sticking post-it notes on a wall, like those exercises in workshops and seminars where everyone writes on their post-it notes, then sticks them in the appropriate place on a wall or whiteboard. Reader, I have no blank walls in my workspace. There’s absolutely nowhere to stick deeply significant sticky-notes, and in any case, the thought of the occupants of Testosterone Towers roaming the house with stray post-it notes clinging to their hoodies and fleeces, is both too vivid and too horrific to contemplate.
Finally, a breakthrough. I’ve sorted my key concepts into a logical order. Now I’m going through twenty-seven transcripts, taking useful quotes and putting them under each concept heading. It’ll make one large, but intelligible document that I can condense into something readably meaningful later.
(Did I hear you mention AI? Certainly not. I will succeed or fail entirely by my own efforts. None of my data is getting fed into any form of artificial intelligence – I wouldn’t dream of it.)
The majority of the historical individuals I’ve encountered during my research have shared a common interest: the love of Scottish music. Aberdonian James Davie certainly falls into this category. His absolute obsession with old Scots tunes and music books does suggest he might nowadays have been diagnosed as somewhere ‘on the spectrum’, but if someone is going to have a special interest, then collecting Scottish music is really a perfectly acceptable one. Well, it seems reasonable to me!
David Baptie, in his Musical Scotland, described him as ‘a man possessed of taste and ability’, noting that he was born around 1783 and died on this day, 19 November, in 1857.
David Baptie, Musical Scotland: Past and Present (1894) p.41
From my point of view, Davie was a close friend of, and collaborator with Dundee collector Andrew Wighton (whose collection is now in the Wighton Centre, Dundee Central Library). I mentioned the other day, a letter written in old age when he despaired that he and Wighton would find anything else of interest in the antiquarian Scottish music field. There are letters to Wighton witnessing Davie’s absolute hatred of English antiquarian ballad collector William Chappell. And what had Chappell done? In his Popular Music of Olden Times, which came out in separate issues before becoming a book, Chappell had claimed that ….
Shock, horror ….!
… some tunes that were claimed to be Scottish, were actually English. (I’m whispering this.)
You can read about the whole argument in my monograph, Our Ancient National Airs, more affordable as paperback or on Kindle, or most affordable by borrowing it from a university or public library!
Remembered for Davie’s Caledonian Repository
I’m not sure, but I have a feeling Davie’s wife predeceased him – I recall him mentioning her not being in good health, in one of his letters to Wighton. So, he may well have been a sad and lonely old man. Certainly, in old age, James Davie became exceptionally grumpy. Perfectly lucid, but very, very bitter. So today, on the 169th anniversary of his death, perhaps I should end with some happier thoughts – he was a flautist, composer and teacher, and published several music collections. I’ve seen one or two of them, but haven’t studied them, as such. There are a number of copies of Davie’s Caledonian Repository extant, largely in a few legal deposit libraries, but also in the Dundonian Wighton Collection. Baptie spoke highly of him, and Wighton was a good friend. And he loved Scottish music!
You may congratulate me! I’ve uploaded half a dozen testimonials in the past few years – but today, I discovered that WordPress was keeping them all to itself, and I needed to create a Testimonials page for myself. It had not automatically created itself, despite assurances to the contrary.
So, as proof that a semi-retired musicologist can battle technology and win, you may now read my testimonials! They’re accessible from the menu on my homepage, but to save you the bother, here’s the link now.
On 16th November 1780, our hero Robert Archibald Smith (editor of the Scotish Minstrel) was born …
In Reading. Yes, you read that correctly. However, Robert Archibald Smith was of Scottish descent. His father was a Paisley weaver, who happened to be working in Reading when R. A. Smith was born. Robert Archibald went back to Paisley, as a weaver, in 1820.
I spent a lot of time thinking about him, when I was writing my PhD and subsequent book, so it’s nice to spend a minute or two celebrating his 246th birthday! Plenty about him in my book (Our Ancient National Airs), and biographical details can be found in Baptie’s Musical Scotland (1894 and reprinted Georg Olms, 1972).
Scotish Minstrel!
And yes, it is spelled ‘Scotish Minstrel’. As I said to students last week, if you look it up correctly, you’ll find it. But if you use the modern spelling of Scottish, you could find a different book entirely, or a misspelling by someone who didn’t copy it down correctly in the first place.
NLS Digital Gallery
You can see the Scotish Minstrel on the National Library of Scotland’s Digital Gallery, here.
Friday 13 November (Well, it would be Friday the Thirteenth!)
The Microsoft outage affected many of us.
For future reference, ‘Join in the Conversation’ messages on this blog normally go straight to my work email account. However, ‘comments’ on individual blog posts aren’t affected by whatever happens to Microsoft.
Just be aware that a comment is public, whereas ‘Join in the Conversation’ messages are private.
On This Day
On 13 November 1854, crusty old Aberdonian James Davie wrote sadly to his friend Andrew Wighton in Dundee,
I now despair of findng anything very interesting now in our line.
It’s strange now to read of an antiquarian despairing of finding interesting old publications, when we today can get excited about old music whose compilers weren’t even yet born in 1854!
And on 13 November 1893, Glaswegian music publisher James S. Kerr died in his Saltcoats home. He was only 52.
The Courier covered our Leng Medal Get-Together with an article and a lovely picture of attendees. What a great night! I’ll write more in due course, but I wanted to share this straight away! (News report by Alan Wilson, The Courier & Advertiser, 11 November 2026.)
My grateful thanks to Dr Erin Farley of the Local History Department for helping me arrange this event, and of course to the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland in Glasgow, for granting me an Athenaeum Award for my research project.
There will be songs, there will be reminiscing. The Leng Medal Scots Song contests have run for one and a quarter centuries. Thousands of kids have entered, hundreds of kids have won medals. So who will be there? Wait and see!
Today, Tuesday 10th November
And I’m in Dundee đŸ˜‰
I’ll write a write-up in the next couple of days!
The event has been flagged up in one of D C Thomson’s local newspapers, The Courier & Advertiser, Tuesday 10 November 2026:-
Last month, I visited Rutherglen cenotaph (war memorial) and found local composer Rose Smith’s elder son’s name, from the Great War (World War 1). I’m remembering him on her behalf, today.
Rutherglen cenotaph
Meanwhile, coloratura soprano Flora Woodman had a fiance, who was gassed and invalided out during the same war. I don’t know his name or what happened to him. But she never married. Happened to a lot of young women of her generation.